Beware of Foreign Currency Trading Frauds
The
advertisements seem too good to pass up. They tout high returns
coupled with low risks from investments in foreign currency (“forex”)
contracts. Sometimes they even offer lucrative employment
opportunities in forex trading.
Do these deals sound too good to be
true? Unfortunately, they are , and investors need to be on guard
against these scams. They may look like a new sophisticated form of
investment opportunity, but in reality they are the same old trap –
financial fraud in fancy garb.
Forex trading can be legitimate for
governments and large institutional investors concerned about
fluctuations in international exchange rates, and it can even be
appropriate for some individual investors. But the average
investor should be wary when it comes to forex offers.
The Commodity Futures Trading Commission
(CFTC) and the North American Securities Administrators Association
(NASAA) warn that off-exchange forex trading by retail investors is at
best extremely risky, and at worst, outright fraud.
What are forex contracts?
Forex
contracts involve the right to buy or sell a certain amount of a
foreign currency at a fixed price in U.S. dollars. Profits or losses
accrue as the exchange rate of that currency fluctuates on the open
market. It is extremely rare that individual traders actually see the
foreign currency. Instead, they typically close out their buy or sell
commitments and calculate net gains or losses based on price changes in
that currency relative to the dollar over time.
Forex markets are among the most active
markets in the world in terms of dollar volume. The participants
include large banks, multinational corporations, governments, and
speculators. Individual traders comprise a very small part of this
market. Because of the volatility in the price of foreign currency,
losses can accrue very rapidly, wiping out an investor’s down payment
in short order.
How do the scams work?
Forex
scams attract customers with sophisticated-sounding offers placed in
newspaper advertisements, radio promotions, or on Internet sites.
Promoters often lure investors with the concept of leverage: the right
to “control” a large amount of foreign currency with an initial payment
representing only a fraction of the total cost. Coupled with
predictions about supposedly inevitable increases in currency prices,
these contracts are said to offer huge returns over a short time, with
little or no downside risk.
In a typical case, investors may be assured
of reaping tens of thousands of dollars in just a few weeks or months,
with an initial investment of only $5,000. Often, the investor’s money
is never actually placed in the market through a legitimate dealer, but
simply diverted – stolen -- for the personal benefit of the con
artists.
What are regulators doing?
The
CFTC is the federal agency with the primary responsibility for
overseeing the commodities markets, including foreign currency trading.
Many state securities regulators also have the right under their state
laws to take action against illegal commodities investments.
Sometimes, the CFTC and the states work together on cases. Some
examples –
>> In
2005, the CFTC and the Commissioner of Corporations of the State of
California sued National Investment Consultants, Inc., and others in US
District Court for the Northern District of California for engaging in
a forex scam involving approximately $2 million in customer
funds. In 2006, the Court ordered restitution and fines amounting
to $3.4 million.
>> Also
in 2005, the CFTC and the Texas State Securities Board (TSSB) engaged
in a cooperative enforcement effort against Premium Income Corp. (PIC)
and its principals. The CFTC and SEC filed an action in U.S.
District Court for the Northern District of Texas and the TSSB filed an
administrative action charging PIC and its principals with engaging in
an illegal $11 million forex operation. To date, the federal court has
found three corporate defendants liable to pay restitution of $12
million and each was assessed a fine of $37 million. The State of Texas
also has obtained cease and desist orders along with various
criminal indictments and convictions. PIC’s president is currently
incarcerated on charges stemming from his forex scam.
>> In
2004, Gregory Blake Baldwin, of Utah, pleaded guilty to fraud after his
firm, Sunstar Funding, accepted $228,500 from 33 investors for
placement into the foreign currency market. Their money was not placed
in the foreign currency market but used to pay some past investors and
for personal expenses.
>> In
2003, the CFTC and the State of Oregon Department of Consumer and
Business Services sued Orion International, Inc., and its principals in
US District Court for the District of Oregon for fraudulently
soliciting over $40 million to participate in a purported forex fund.
Orion, and its president Russell Cline, misappropriated virtually all
the customer funds. In 2006, the Court entered fines and restitution
orders against the defendants totaling almost $150 million. Cline is
currently incarcerated on charges stemming from his forex scam.
>> In
2002, the CFTC, SEC and State of Utah filed action against a company
known as “4NExchange” for violations of state and federal laws as the
firm’s principals illegally offered foreign currency contracts through
an alleged Ponzi scheme that cost investors nearly $15 million.
What are the warning signs of fraud?
If
you are solicited by a company that claims to trade foreign currencies
and asks you to invest funds, you should be very careful. Watch out for
the following warning signs:
1. Be wary of promises that sound too good to
be true: “You can make six figure profits within a year; forex
investments are very low risk; You can double your money.”
Get-rich-quick schemes, including those involving foreign currency
trading, tend to be frauds.
2. Be skeptical about unsolicited phone calls
offering investments, especially those from out-of-state salespersons
or companies that are unfamiliar.
3. Be especially cautious if you have
acquired a large sum of cash recently and are looking for an investment
vehicle. In particular, retirees with access to their retirement
funds may be attractive targets for fraudulent operators. Getting your
money back once it is gone can be difficult or impossible.
4. Be wary of high-pressure efforts to
convince you to send or transfer cash immediately to the firm, via
overnight delivery or the Internet.
5. Be smart about the money you do put at
risk. Even when purchased through the most reputable dealer,
forex investments are extremely risky. If you are tempted to
invest, make sure you understand these products and above all, only
invest what you can afford to lose. Don’t invest your rent money
in a forex contract.
Investigate before you invest
Investors
should make sure that anyone offering a forex investment is properly
licensed and has a reputable business history. The public can obtain
information about any firm or individual registered with the CFTC,
including any actions taken against a registrant, through the National
Futures Association (NFA) Background Affiliation Status Information
Center (BASIC), available on the NFA website. You can also find out if someone is registered by calling the National Futures Association at 1-800-676-4632.
The CFTC’s Division of Enforcement has
established a toll-free telephone number to assist members of the
public in reporting possible violations of the commodities laws.
Call 866-FON-CFTC (866-366-2382). In addition, if you think that
you have been a victim of a forex scam, you can report it through a
form on the CFTC's website, or by mail addressed to the Office of Cooperative Enforcement, CFTC, 1155 21st St., NW, Washington, DC 20581.
The securities regulator in your state or province also may be able to help. Click here for contact inforamtion for your state or provincial securities regulator.